Real Estate News

Transparent Commissions Gain Traction Among Home Sellers

Home sellers are embracing transparent commission structures as the real estate industry shifts toward greater fee clarity. This trend empowers sellers with better understanding of costs

flareAI Services

23 Sep 2025 — 6 min read

Quick Listen:

Podcast

The real estate market has always been a maze of fees, negotiations, and fine print, but a seismic shift is underway. Home sellers in places like West Michigan and Florida are no longer content to sign on the dotted line without asking hard questions about what they're paying for. The catalyst? A landmark legal decision that's forcing the industry to rethink how commissions are disclosed and negotiated. This isn't just a policy tweak it's a movement toward transparency that's empowering sellers to demand clarity, and tech platforms like SideDoor are stepping in to make it happen.

Home buying or selling shouldn't mean paying for services you don't use or need. Now, with new rules, you can choose exactly what you pay for. Side Door's smart match engine connects you with vetted agents offering flexible service levels, so you pay only for what you use. Keep the guidance, skip the extras, and save thousands and still get the keys in hand. Join Side Door for FREE today!

Transparent Commissions Post-NAR Settlement

In October 2023, the Burnett v. National Association of Realtors lawsuit shook the real estate world. The verdict found the National Association of Realtors (NAR) and major brokerages liable for a price-fixing conspiracy that inflated commission fees, often costing sellers around 6% of their home's sale price a rate far higher than in countries like Australia or the UK. This decision, handed down in the Western District of Missouri, mandated clearer disclosure of fees and opened the door to more negotiable commission structures. For sellers in markets like Holland, Michigan, and Florida, this means a chance to break down the traditional one-size-fits-all agent package.

SideDoor, a PropTech platform, is capitalizing on this shift by offering a menu of à la carte services. Instead of locking into a full-service agent, sellers can pick exactly what they need professional photography, open house coordination, or targeted marketing while skipping what they don't. It's a model that's resonating in West Michigan, where frugal homeowners are eager to control costs, and in Florida, where a competitive market demands flexibility.

Emerging Trends: A New Era for Commission Practices

The NAR settlement didn't just change the rules; it sparked a cultural shift. According to U.S. News, commissions are now more openly negotiable, with sellers able to challenge the standard 6% rate. Yet, as Yahoo Finance reports, these changes haven't drastically lowered costs across the board. Many sellers still face high fees unless they actively negotiate or use platforms that simplify the process.

Enter the rise of à la carte services. PropTech platforms are stepping up with tools that let sellers compare agent fees side by side, breaking down what each service costs and what it delivers. This is a game-changer for title companies, lenders, and inspectors, who can now showcase their value directly to consumers. In Florida, for instance, title companies like Chicago Title's Holland office are integrating with platforms to offer transparent pricing, making it easier for sellers to see the full picture.

Real-World Impact: Transparency in Action

Picture a seller in West Michigan, sifting through agent proposals for their cozy Holland bungalow. Using a platform like SideDoor, they compare service packages $2,000 for a marketing campaign versus $5,000 for a full-service agent and negotiate a deal that saves them thousands. This isn't hypothetical; it's happening in markets where transparency is becoming a competitive edge. In Florida, where luxury condos and beachfront properties dominate, sellers are using similar tools to bundle services from lenders like Lake Michigan Credit Union and agents, ensuring every dollar spent aligns with their needs.

This model isn't just about savings it's about access. Agents who might not land high-end listings can now compete by offering specialized services, like staging or digital marketing, through platforms that connect them directly with sellers. It's a win-win: sellers get tailored services, and agents tap into deals they'd otherwise miss.

Challenges: Navigating a Transparent Landscape

Transparency sounds great, but it's not without hurdles. Start-ups like SideDoor face skepticism from consumers accustomed to polished websites from big players like Real Estate One. As one objection notes, competitors in the real estate space spend heavily on marketing, making it tough for newer platforms to stand out. A less flashy website can raise doubts about credibility, even if the service delivers.

There's also the risk of misinterpretation. Some sellers hear “transparent commissions” and assume it means “free” or “dirt-cheap.” In reality, lower commissions can sometimes lead to reduced agent effort, like fewer showings or less aggressive marketing. And in competitive markets, full-service agents still dominate, leveraging their budgets and networks to secure listings. As Realtor.com points out, sellers need to weigh the trade-offs of cutting costs versus maximizing exposure.

Opportunities: Redefining the Real Estate Game

Despite these challenges, the opportunities are immense. Transparency is becoming a differentiator in crowded markets like West Michigan and Florida. Platforms that integrate commission calculators and service menus are simplifying decisions for sellers, while fostering collaboration among agents, title companies, and lenders. In Holland, for example, local firms like Premier Lakeshore are embracing these tools to offer bundled services that prioritize seller needs.

Social media is amplifying this shift. Platforms like Instagram and TikTok key channels for SideDoor's audience are buzzing with agents and firms showcasing transparent pricing. A quick scroll through Todd VanHaitsma's Instagram reveals how agents are using short videos to demystify fees, building trust with tech-savvy sellers. This regional focus, paired with tech-driven tools, is creating a new standard for how real estate deals are done.

A Memorable The Future of Selling Smart

The NAR settlement has cracked open a door that sellers in Michigan and Florida are eagerly stepping through. Transparency isn't just a buzzword it's a tool that's leveling the playing field, letting homeowners take control of their costs and choices. Platforms like SideDoor are leading the charge, offering clarity in a market that's long been opaque. But the journey isn't over. As PropTech evolves, expect AI-driven tools to predict optimal commission rates and streamline negotiations even further.

For now, sellers have a clear path forward: use tech platforms to compare services, ask tough questions, and negotiate based on local market trends. The real estate world is changing, and those who embrace transparency will come out ahead whether they're selling a lakeside cottage in Holland or a condo in Miami.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do à la carte real estate services work and can they save money for home sellers?

À la carte real estate services allow home sellers to pick exactly what they need from a menu of options like professional photography, open house coordination, or targeted marketing, while skipping services they don't want. Platforms like SideDoor enable sellers to compare service packages side by side, with some sellers saving thousands by choosing $2,000 marketing campaigns over $5,000 full-service agents, though sellers should weigh cost savings against potential reduced agent effort.

Are transparent real estate commissions actually making it cheaper to buy or sell homes?

While the NAR settlement has made commissions more openly negotiable, transparent pricing hasn't drastically lowered costs across the board unless sellers actively negotiate or use platforms that simplify the process. The key benefit is increased clarity and control over what sellers pay for, allowing them to make informed decisions about which services provide value for their specific situation, rather than automatically accepting traditional commission structures.

What is the NAR settlement and how does it affect real estate commissions for home sellers?

The NAR settlement refers to the October 2023 Burnett v. National Association of Realtors lawsuit verdict that found NAR and major brokerages liable for price-fixing conspiracy that inflated commission fees to around 6% of home sale prices. This landmark decision now requires clearer disclosure of fees and allows for more negotiable commission structures, giving home sellers the power to challenge the standard 6% rate and choose à la carte services instead of full-service agent packages.

Disclaimer: The above helpful resources content contains personal opinions and experiences. The information provided is for general knowledge and does not constitute professional advice.

You may also be interested in: Side Door