Real Estate News

Spring Homebuying Season Concludes with Subdued Growth

The spring homebuying season concludes with modest growth as buyers navigate changing market dynamics. Inventory levels, interest rates, and economic factors contribute to subdued activity this year

flareAI Services

25 Dec 2025 — 6 min read

Quick Listen:

Podcast

Springtime usually signals a vibrant surge in real estate, with for-sale signs dotting neighborhoods like blooming flowers. Yet, the markets in Michigan and Florida reflected a more tempered reality. High borrowing costs, limited inventory, and a transformative shift in real estate commission structures created a cautious landscape for buyers and sellers alike. From the breezy shores of Lake Michigan to the sun-drenched streets of Tampa Bay, the season's subdued growth underscores both challenges and opportunities for proptech innovators and real estate professionals navigating this evolving terrain.

Home buying or selling shouldn't mean paying for services you don't use or need. Now, with new rules, you can choose exactly what you pay for. Side Door's smart match engine connects you with vetted agents offering flexible service levels, so you pay only for what you use. Keep the guidance, skip the extras, and save thousands and still get the keys in hand. Join Side Door for FREE today!

Spring Homebuying Season Closes with Modest Gains

In Michigan, where spring typically ignites a flurry of open houses, the 2025 market unfolded with restraint. Reports from the Greater Regional Alliance of Realtors and Michigan Realtors highlighted modest sales growth, dampened by elevated interest rates that curbed buyer enthusiasm. In West Michigan, cities like Grand Rapids saw an uptick in listings, but homes lingered longer than the brisk pace of spring 2023. Holland, Michigan, with its picturesque lakeside charm, grappled with strong demand overshadowed by affordability challenges, particularly for first-time buyers squeezed by rising prices.

Florida's market, a perennial draw for retirees and transplants, followed a similar trajectory. Tampa Bay and Orlando maintained steady interest, driven by out-of-state buyers and remote workers, but soaring property insurance costs often a hidden hurdle tempered growth. The Florida Realtors Association noted resilience in the state's housing market, yet the absence of the explosive growth seen in prior years pointed to insurance premiums and seasonal migration patterns as key constraints.

Navigating the New Commission Landscape

A seismic shift in real estate transactions loomed large this spring, driven by the National Association of Realtor's (NAR) settlement finalized in late 2024. This landmark agreement, detailed in a U.S. News article, dismantled the longstanding practice of seller's agents automatically splitting commissions with buyer's agents. The result is a more negotiable but complex commission structure, requiring buyers and sellers in Michigan and Florida to approach transactions with greater financial acumen.

Despite hopes for significant cost savings, the reality is more nuanced. A Yahoo Finance report indicates that commission changes haven't drastically reduced expenses for most. In West Michigan, commissions still hover around 2.5% to 3% per side, even with negotiation. In Florida's competitive coastal markets, sellers often maintain traditional commission splits to ensure maximum exposure, leaving buyers to navigate a market where transparency is improving but savings remain modest.

Regional Dynamics and Buyer Strategies

In Holland, Michigan, the tension between desirability and affordability is palpable. The town's tree-lined streets and proximity to Lake Michigan make it a magnet for buyers, but median home prices around $350,000 clash with the region's median income of $65,000, according to a University of Michigan economic forecast. First-time buyers, often Millennials or Gen Z, are turning to digital tools to stretch their budgets. Virtual tours and AI-driven MLS searches allow them to compare properties across zip codes without the time and expense of in-person visits, a trend reshaping how buyers engage with the market.

Florida's dynamics differ but carry their own complexities. Tampa Bay remains a hotspot for out-of-state buyers, yet annual insurance costs sometimes exceeding $5,000 for a modest home are a growing deterrent. In Orlando, investors eyeing vacation rentals fuel demand, but rising property taxes give even seasoned buyers pause. Proptech platforms are stepping up, offering tools that calculate total ownership costs, including taxes and insurance, to provide clarity before buyers commit. As Realtor.com notes, these digital innovations are becoming indispensable in today's intricate market.

Challenges in a Shifting Market

Affordability remains the Achille's heel for Michigan's housing market. Young buyers, burdened by student loans and childcare costs, face a scarcity of starter homes, making homeownership feel like a distant dream. The new commission rules add another layer of complexity: buyers must now understand their agent's fees upfront, a process that can feel overwhelming without clear guidance. In Florida, the insurance crisis casts a long shadow, with some homeowners facing premiums that have doubled in just two years. List With Clever advises that commission negotiation is possible, but success hinges on local market conditions and an agent's flexibility.

These challenges are not without silver linings. The NAR settlement's push for transparency has spurred innovation. Proptech firms are rolling out calculators that demystify transaction costs under the new rules, empowering buyers with data. In West Michigan, some brokerages are experimenting with flat-fee models to attract cost-conscious buyers, while in Florida, digital listing platforms capitalize on the state's enduring appeal to retirees and investors. These tools don't just streamline processes they foster trust in a market where clarity is now paramount.

Opportunities for Innovation and Adaptation

The subdued spring season has highlighted opportunities for real estate professionals to adapt. In Michigan, brokerages are leaning into transparent fee structures to build confidence among first-time buyers. Proptech platforms, meanwhile, are enhancing user experiences with AI-driven tools that streamline communication between buyers and brokers while ensuring compliance with new commission disclosure rules. In Florida, where long-term demand for coastal and retirement properties remains strong, digital platforms are positioning themselves as essential partners for investors navigating high insurance costs and tax burdens.

These innovations align with broader market needs. Buyers, particularly younger demographics, are increasingly digital-first, relying on platforms that offer real-time data and cost breakdowns. For real estate services providers, this shift underscores the need to invest in localized, user-friendly tools that address regional pain points whether it's affordability in Holland or insurance costs in Tampa Bay. By prioritizing transparency and technology, the industry can turn today's challenges into tomorrow's competitive edge.

Looking Ahead: A Market at a Crossroads

Michigan and Florida find themselves at a pivotal moment. The market's cautious pace reflects broader economic realities higher interest rates, strained budgets, and a commission structure still finding its footing. Yet, within these constraints lies opportunity. Proptech platforms are empowering buyers with tools like AI-driven price comparisons and virtual tours, saving time and money. Brokerages are adapting, too, with clearer fee models designed to rebuild trust. University of Michigan economists forecast steady activity into summer, while Florida's outlook hinges on potential insurance reforms that could unleash pent-up demand. For real estate professionals, the path forward is clear: embrace transparency, harness technology, and meet buyers where they are. In a market holding its breath, those who innovate today will define the seasons ahead.

The spring of 2025 may not have delivered the robust growth many anticipated, but it has set the stage for a more transparent, tech-driven future. As buyers and sellers navigate this evolving landscape, the tools and strategies they adopt now will shape not just their transactions but the broader trajectory of real estate in Michigan, Florida, and beyond. For an industry at a crossroads, the next steps rooted in clarity and innovation will determine who thrives in the seasons to come.

Frequently Asked Questions

How did the 2025 spring homebuying season perform in Michigan and Florida?

The 2025 spring homebuying season in Michigan and Florida showed modest growth rather than the robust activity typically seen in prior years. High interest rates, limited inventory, and elevated costs including property insurance premiums in Florida dampened buyer enthusiasm. While cities like Grand Rapids saw increased listings, homes stayed on the market longer, and affordability challenges particularly affected first-time buyers in markets like Holland, Michigan.

How have the new real estate commission rules affected home buying costs?

Following the National Association of Realtor's 2024 settlement, commission structures became more negotiable, but savings haven't been as dramatic as many hoped. In Michigan and Florida, commissions still typically range from 2.5% to 3% per side, with many sellers maintaining traditional splits to ensure maximum property exposure. The primary change has been increased transparency, requiring buyers to understand their agent's fees upfront before beginning the home search process.

What challenges are first-time homebuyers facing in Michigan's housing market?

First-time buyers in Michigan face a triple challenge of affordability constraints, limited starter home inventory, and complex new commission structures. In desirable areas like Holland, median home prices around $350,000 clash with the region's median income of $65,000, making homeownership difficult for younger buyers already burdened by student loans and childcare costs. However, many are turning to digital tools like virtual tours and AI-driven MLS searches to compare properties efficiently and stretch their budgets further.

Disclaimer: The above helpful resources content contains personal opinions and experiences. The information provided is for general knowledge and does not constitute professional advice.

You may also be interested in: Condos for Sale Near Me Surge in Coastal Cities