Real Estate News

Sellers Withdrew from Market as Inventory Stabilized

As housing inventory stabilizes, sellers are pulling back from the market. This shift signals a new equilibrium in real estate, impacting pricing strategies and buyer opportunities across the market

flareAI Services

19 Dec 2025 — 8 min read

Quick Listen:

Podcast

Imagine the quiet unraveling of a once-frenzied market: in the misty mornings of West Michigan's lakeside towns and the balmy afternoons along Florida's Gulf Coast, "For Sale" signs are vanishing faster than they appear. Homeowners, once eager to cash in, are now stepping back, creating an unexpected equilibrium in housing inventory. This shift, detailed in our analysis of Sellers Withdrew From Market as Inventory Stabilized in Michigan and Florida, hands buyers unprecedented leverage choices abound, and price escalations have tempered. But amid this calm, a seismic change looms: the National Association of Realtor's (NAR) settlement reshaping commission structures, compelling agents, sellers, and buyers to recalibrate their financial expectations. These rules demand explicit negotiations, turning opaque traditions into transparent transactions. In this evolving arena, property technology (PropTech) emerges as a vital navigator, offering data-driven clarity to all players.

Home buying or selling shouldn't mean paying for services you don't use or need. Now, with new rules, you can choose exactly what you pay for. Side Door's smart match engine connects you with vetted agents offering flexible service levels, so you pay only for what you use. Keep the guidance, skip the extras, and save thousands and still get the keys in hand. Join Side Door for FREE today!

Market Equilibrium and PropTech's Role

The housing landscape across Michigan and Florida in the summer of 2025 played out like a meticulously scripted drama, with sellers retreating amid persistent high interest rates and faint economic uncertainties. Withdrawals accelerated, catching industry veterans off guard, while inventory long plagued by extremes settled into a balanced state. In Michigan, median home prices teetered near the brink of accessibility, translating this stability into fewer competitive frays and greater bargaining space for purchasers. Florida mirrored the pattern: fresh listings dwindled to a mere dribble, yet standing supply remained firm, restoring buyer influence absent since the post-pandemic cooldown.

This development carries profound weight, particularly for those long excluded by escalating expenses. A PBS NewsHour analysis reveals that sales of existing homes sank to a near-30-year nadir in 2024, as reported by the National Association of Realtors just last month. Compounding this, a CNN survey from the prior year indicated that 86 percent of renters aspired to ownership but were thwarted by costs, against a backdrop of a national housing deficit reaching 5 million units as estimated by economists in 2023. With inventory now leveling, these prospective owners drawn to Holland's vibrant tulip heritage or Florida's idyllic retiree communities perceive an opening. Yet the narrative deepens: this poise extends beyond physical assets, igniting innovation in PropTech, where digital tools dissect market pulses with precision.

Platforms akin to those in the SideDoor network exemplify this surge, delivering instant notifications on delisted properties to illuminate supply fluctuations. In West Michigan's premium lakefront niches around Holland, proprietors employ these systems to assess demand discreetly, sidestepping premature market immersion. Florida's tech-savvy cohort, spanning Miami's high-rise investors to Sarasota's seasonal migrants, relies on forecasting algorithms to determine if patience outperforms prompt divestment. Layered atop these dynamics is the NAR's late-2024 accord, which dismantled entrenched commission norms. Sellers can no longer universally proffer buyer agent compensation through multiple listing services (MLS); instead, disclosures and bilateral pacts prevail. Per U.S. News & World Report, listings must delineate seller contributions to buyer agents or none at all while buyers formalize agency contracts outlining agent remuneration prior to viewings. This shift toward candor, while ostensibly liberating, has sown doubt among reticent sellers, amplifying their pause.

Emerging Trends: Stabilized Inventory Meets Seller Hesitation

Deep in Michigan's core, empirical evidence sketches a portrait of calculated forbearance. Multiple listing service dispatches from Grand Rapids and Holland indicate supply durations edging toward parity roughly four to five months, a stark contrast to the under-two-month scramble of 2022. Rather than discounting aggressively, sellers are retracting offers, wagering on enduring appeal from telecommuters flocking to cost-effective, picturesque havens. Corroborating this, a Western Michigan University inquiry from earlier this year documented a 15 percent rise in suspended postings across West Michigan, as stakeholders pondered the commission reconfiguration. Post-NAR, the conventional 5-6 percent aggregate equitably divided has fragmented into granular haggling. Sellers could extend 2.5 percent to buyer representatives to boost visibility, yet skimping risks burdening buyers with residuals, which may dampen pursuits.

Florida's cadence resonates analogously, infused with subtropical nuances. Through September, Tampa and Miami registered a 10 percent year-over-year plunge in novel listings, according to state Realtor metrics, coinciding with inventory reminiscent of 2019's steadiness. Here, affordability strains intensify skyrocketing insurance and storm apprehensions exacerbate the nationwide rate malaise. J.P. Morgan Research anticipates a tempered 3 percent national price uptick in 2025, with mortgage rates marginally receding to 6.7 percent by December. Presidential policies under Trump, encompassing fiscal adjustments and migration postures, introduce ambiguity: might frontier alterations inundate rentals, buoying transactions indirectly? Amid such enigmas, sellers withdraw. On commissions, Yahoo Finance observes scant abatement fees linger near antecedent norms, circa $21,000 to $24,000 for median dwellings. PropTech illuminates: virtual scheduling applications enable Florida intermediaries to showcase assets privately, sustaining momentum sans overt listings.

Spanning these realms, innovation spans divides. Anticipatory instruments pinpoint retraction epicenters Holland's leisure lodgings or Tampa's verdant retreats empowering advisors to tailor timelines. Beyond metrics, this constitutes prescience in an era dominated by reserve.

Case Studies: Regional Insights

Traverse Holland, Michigan, amid autumn's crisp embrace, and the scarcity of signage speaks volumes. Custodians of Lake Macatawa's tranquil expanses maintain their vigil. Area firms note a proliferation of subterranean dialogues: covert exchanges through secure applications, probing receptivity absent MLS vows. A singular platform chronicled 20 percent escalation in confidential viewings during 2025's penultimate quarter versus prior. The catalyst? NAR's pivot spotlights remuneration propositions in every entry, dissuading proprietors averse to buyer split skirmishes. As guidance from Clever Real Estate posits, consumers ought to canvass several representatives to calibrate benchmarks national listing levies average 2.82 percent, buyer facets 2.75 percent metamorphosing obscurity into leverage.

Contrast with Florida, where senior sanctuaries like The Villages thrum with latent promise. Equilibrium persists, yet proprietors agonize over settlement sequelae: withholding buyer incentives could halve expositions by 30 percent, gauging nascent sector murmurs. Virtual conduits advance immersive simulations via PropTech permit interest assays sans postings, safeguarding seclusion. Miami's vertical enclaves foster augmented discreet pacts, with fees adjudicated interparty. Diverging from erstwhile universal tenders, U.S. News affirms empowerment in discourse: seasoned envoys can reintegrate outlays into proceeds, notably in elevated arenas. Such vignettes transcend outliers; they herald a sector waltzing with openness.

Key Challenges, Limitations, and Risks

Foremost among hurdles is seller ambivalence. The NAR accord eradicated neither fees nor their essence dispelling the myth: they endure, merely unveiled. Effective from August 2024's midpoint, acquirers shoulder deficits should seller tenders fall shy of agent accords, injecting terminus shocks. In Michigan's unpretentious spheres, this could signify $5,000 supplemental for a $300,000 abode, drawing from sector hypotheticals. Proprietors view amplified exposition perils: rationale for unveiling if discourses haul emoluments center-stage? A Forbes Advisor dissection accentuates the pervasive frost irrespective of burgeoning provision and decelerating escalations, legions of acquirers defer for Treasury-linked diminutions, eschewing Federal caprices. According to Forbes, this year's balmy season proved tepid, with augmenting reservoirs affording suitors alternatives and clout amid Federal Reserve slash anticipations yet rates, tethered to decennial securities, ascended late 2024 notwithstanding dual policy easings.

Acquirer abrasion endures. Fiscal strains gnaw regionally Michigan's rent surges parallel Florida's premium surges while diminished fees might erode intermediary cohorts. PropTech chronicles qualms but cannot exorcise them. Perils? Extended stasis might impede vicinities, from Holland's visitor influx to Tampa's edifice surge. Dispelling fallacies: envoys neither toil gratis nor invariably diminish; variances hinge on locale, envoy, and clime. As Clever counsels, canvass openly vet two to three, harness asset allure via preparatory enhancements like coatings to ameliorate pacts. Equilibrium demands duality: adaptability for multitudes, novel barriers alike.

Navigating these waters requires savvy. For instance, sellers might benchmark local norms say, offering 2.0-2.5 percent to buyer agents in competitive Florida pockets to sustain traffic while buyers ink nonexclusive pacts for flexibility, limiting obligations to agent-sourced viewings. Hypotheticals clarify: pre-settlement, a $400,000 sale yielded $24,000 total commissions, seller-borne. Post-, if seller tenders 2.5 percent ($10,000) to buyer agent but buyer pact stipulates 3 percent, the acquirer bridges $4,000 yet negotiations could rebate excesses into pricing, neutralizing nets. Such scenarios, per industry exemplars, underscore variability sans universal thrift.

Opportunities and Business Impacts

Acquirers reap lucidity from equilibrated reservoirs. PropTech conduits facilitate interregional juxtapositions Michigan homesteads against Florida cottages unearthing retraction motifs for opportune strikes. Within 6.7 percent rate environs, as J.P. Morgan forecasts, this gleams: subdued 3 percent accrual reallocates sway.

Proprietors too ascend: digital reckoners simulate antecedent versus contemporary NAR tableaux, bolstering deferrals or astute inscriptions. Florida elders, notably, deploy AI to emulate suitor fluxes covertly.

PropTech entities thrive paramount. Arraying as datum confederates amid remuneration bewilderment envisage AI delineating 2.5 percent buyer tenders portends proliferation. As ices melt, these bastions steer metamorphoses, transmuting intricacy into supremacy. Sellers, for one, might leverage home enhancements 76 percent undertake such, targeting kitchens (31 percent) or exteriors to diminish perceived workloads, coaxing concessions from 3 percent to 2.5 percent on high-value assets. Buyers, meanwhile, profit from checkboxes in agency forms, confining searches to seller-subsidized listings, evading outlays.

Expert Insights and Future Outlook

Michigan Realtors alongside University of Michigan habitat savants envision unwavering poise for West Michigan: perpetual equipoise, albeit inscription augmentation restrained to solitary numerals. "Proprietors orchestrate extended stratagems," a Grand Rapids convener relayed in latter symposium, mirroring NAR-spawned circumspection.

Florida choruses align: Florida Realtors Association luminaries illuminate numeral dissemination ascent pinpointed promulgations countering paucity. PropTech dependence for discourse bolstering? Foreordained, affirm they, as emoluments evolve bespoke.

Prospectus: Sustain this, or macroeconomic veers Treasury lapses or doctrinal swerves entice recidivism? J.P. Morgan envisions "predominantly congealed" 2025, with tempered 3 percent expansion and scant solicitation through extant domicile conveyances. The inquiry suspends akin to dawn haze veiling Lake Michigan. Yet glimmers persist: Yahoo's scrutiny posits enduring parity in outlays, sans seismic thrift, urging perspicacity in pacts. Prepare via agent auditions, locale reconnaissance, and digital auxiliaries steps toward mastery in flux.

Charting Deliberate Strides

From Michigan's undulating sands to Florida's boundless vistas, proprietor's tactical withdrawals amid equilibrated reservoirs denote a crucial interlude a sector inhaling deeply. NAR's remuneration revamp infuses narrative convolutions, exacting discourse acumen over inertial partitions. Nonetheless, from tumult blooms vista: PropTech's luminous beacons charting trajectories for inaugural nesters, equity sentinels, and adaptive envoys. A verity abides this transcends inertia; it's transmutation. Within abodes we pursue and treasure, the habitat chronicle advances not in tumult, but deliberate strides onward. To harness this, consult seasoned agents or explore commission estimators empowerment awaits the informed.

Frequently Asked Questions

Why are home sellers withdrawing from the market in Michigan and Florida?

Home sellers in Michigan and Florida are pulling back due to persistent high interest rates, economic uncertainties, and confusion over the NAR commission settlement that took effect in August 2024. The new rules require explicit negotiation of buyer agent compensation rather than blanket offers through MLS, causing many sellers to hesitate as they evaluate how to structure commissions. Additionally, stabilized inventory levels mean sellers no longer feel pressured to list immediately, allowing them to wait for more favorable conditions.

How has the NAR settlement changed real estate commissions for buyers and sellers?

The NAR settlement eliminated the practice of sellers universally offering buyer agent compensation through multiple listing services. Now, sellers must explicitly disclose what they'll contribute to buyer agents (if anything), while buyers must sign agency contracts outlining agent compensation before home viewings. This means buyers may need to cover the gap if a seller's offer falls short of their agent's fee for example, paying an additional $4,000 out-of-pocket if the seller offers 2.5% but the buyer's agent agreement specifies 3% on a $400,000 home.

What opportunities does stabilized housing inventory create for homebuyers in 2025?

Stabilized inventory gives buyers significantly more leverage and choices, with supply durations reaching a balanced 4-5 months in markets like West Michigan a stark contrast to the under-two-month frenzy of 2022. Buyers can take advantage of reduced bidding wars, negotiate pricing more effectively, and use PropTech platforms to compare properties across regions. With mortgage rates forecast to ease to 6.7% by December 2025 and only modest 3% price increases expected nationally, prospective homeowners particularly first-time buyers previously priced out now have a genuine opening to enter the market.

Disclaimer: The above helpful resources content contains personal opinions and experiences. The information provided is for general knowledge and does not constitute professional advice.

You may also be interested in: Townhomes for Sale Near Me Appeal to Young Families